November 19, 2026
At the end of January 2026, Lake Forest had 30 detached single-family homes for sale. Sellers who closed that month received 99.8% of their original list price on average. One year earlier, in January 2025, the same Midwest Real Estate Data report showed 47 homes for sale and sellers receiving 95.9% of original list. Both were January in the same town, and the results were nearly four points apart. That gap is the best guide we have for a buyer who has settled on the North Shore and is deciding whether to look at Lake Forest between now and February or wait for spring.
Winter reliably cuts the number of homes to choose from. It does not reliably cut the price. Whether a winter buyer gets any room to negotiate depends on how fast the homes that are listed go under contract, and that pace has changed sharply from one year to the next.
All figures below are for detached single-family homes in Lake Forest, from MRED's Local Market Update for January 2026, which compares each figure with January 2025.
| January figure | January 2025 | January 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| New listings | 28 | 11 |
| Under contract | 12 | 11 |
| Closed sales | 15 | 16 |
| Percent of original list price received | 95.9% | 99.8% |
| Average market time | 76 days | 56 days |
| Homes for sale at month end | 47 | 30 |
The number of buyers committing to homes barely changed: 12 went under contract in January 2025 and 11 in January 2026. The number of homes for sale changed a great deal. In January 2025, 12 contracts against 47 homes meant about a quarter of the month-end inventory went under contract in a single month. In January 2026, 11 contracts against 30 homes meant more than a third did.
The softer pricing in January 2025 fits the looser ratio. Homes averaged 76 days on the market, and sellers gave up about four percent from their original asking price. In January 2026 a similar number of buyers had far fewer homes to choose from. Market time fell to 56 days, and the original-list figure rose to nearly full price.
Only 11 new detached listings came on the market in January 2026. Over the 12 months that ended that January, Lake Forest had 382 new listings, or about 32 a month. So a January buyer was choosing from roughly a third of a typical month's new supply, plus whatever had been listed since fall and not yet sold.
The January 2026 median sale price was $1,502,500, compared with $1,175,000 in January 2025. With only 16 and 15 closings in those months, the median can swing on a handful of large sales, and MRED notes in the report that single-month activity "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size." Winter prices in Lake Forest show whether a few large estates happened to close that month, not whether the town's values moved.
MRED's Local Market Update for September 2026 is the most recent month on hand. Its data are current as of October 14, 2026. Lake Forest ended September 2026 with 51 detached homes for sale, down from 59 at the end of September 2025. New listings in September 2026 fell to 23 from 31 a year earlier. Seventeen homes went under contract in each of those Septembers.
Apply the same ratio as above. In September 2025, 17 contracts against 59 homes for sale meant about 29% of inventory went under contract in the month. In September 2026, 17 contracts against 51 homes meant one in three. Sellers who closed in September 2026 received 99.9% of their original list price, compared with 98.4% in September 2025.
Fall 2026 started with fewer homes for sale than fall 2025 and the same number of buyers committing each month. That looks more like the tight January of 2026 than the looser January of 2025. A buyer who expects winter sellers to come down several points from their asking price is working from a pattern that last showed up two winters ago.
The 12-month figures also matter. Over the 12 months that ended in September 2026, Lake Forest detached homes averaged 58 days on the market and sold for 98.9% of original list, with a median sale price of $1,400,000 across 246 closings. September's 31-day average market time is about half of that 12-month figure, so some months of the year must run well above 58 days. A home that has been listed since late summer and is still on the market in December may be one of those slower listings. Those homes are where a winter buyer is most likely to find a seller willing to negotiate. A home listed fresh in January, in a month with 11 new listings, usually is not.
When resale inventory is thin, new construction can look like a way to find more options. In Lake Forest, the largest recent project sold its for-sale homes before the last building was finished, and the newest approval adds only three units.
Kelmscott Park is the largest recent residential project downtown, at Laurel Avenue, Western Avenue and Franklin Place. The City of Lake Forest describes it as 159 units: 12 single-family homes, 36 condominiums and 111 apartments. In its November 2, 2026 City Council packet, the City reported that as of April 30, 2026, the apartments were complete and occupied, and the 12 single-family homes were complete and sold. All 12 units in the second condominium building had been sold while it was still under construction.
The newest approval is much smaller. City Council gave final approval on October 5, 2026, to a two-story building of about 10,800 square feet at the southeast corner of Westminster and Oakwood. It will replace a farmhouse with three condominiums over underground parking. Patch reported on October 8 that no construction start or completion timeline had been announced. The City's Plan Commission records list the owner as Westwood LF Development LLC, held equally by Lynch Construction and Ken Alderidge.
On the west side, a phased condominium development along North McKinley Road has added buildings at 725, 705 and 711 North McKinley. Bleck Engineering's project page lists those phases at 14, 6 and 6 units, dated 2018, 2020 and 2024.
None of these projects is large enough to fill the gap between a January with 11 new listings and a typical month with about 30. The McKinley Road condominiums went up in phases of 6 to 14 units over six years, and Westwood will add three. For a winter buyer, nearly all of the choice is the resale inventory.
For a buyer who is downsizing or wants a lock-and-leave condo or townhome while settling in, the numbers are smaller still. Lake Forest had 3 attached homes for sale at the end of January 2026, down from 6 a year earlier. The count was 8 at the end of September 2026. Attached homes that closed in September 2026 sold for 101.3% of original list after an average of 12 days on the market. Over the 12 months that ended in September 2026, attached new listings fell to 54 from 73 the year before.
With three to eight attached homes for sale at the end of those months, a condo or townhome buyer may have only a handful of units to choose from at any one time. A buyer looking for a condo or townhome this winter should have financing settled and be ready to tour within a day or two of a new listing. Spending a quick hour with our mortgage calculator before the holidays will help.
The figure to track this winter is the one worked out above for each month: how many homes went under contract in a month compared with how many were for sale at month end. When that share drops toward a quarter, as it did in January 2025, original-list figures have softened and market times have run long. When it stays near a third, as in January 2026 and September 2026, sellers have held close to full price.
Within the market, separate listings by when they came on. A home first listed in September or October and still for sale in mid-January has been tested by the fall buyers and not chosen yet. That is a different negotiation from a home listed the week after New Year's Day into one of the thinnest months of the year. In a town where the 12-month median sale price was $1,400,000 through September 2026, a few points of negotiating room is a large amount of money. A buyer should know which of those two kinds of listing they are looking at before writing an offer.
Waiting for spring will bring more homes onto the market. The 12-month count of about 30 new listings a month means some months well above January's 11 for that average to hold. Spring will also bring the buyers who waited. The buyers who were active in January 2026 had fewer homes to compete over, and the original-list figures show sellers rarely had to come down.
Are Lake Forest homes cheaper in January? The detached median was $1,175,000 in January 2025 and $1,502,500 in January 2026. With 15 and 16 closings, each month's median depends mostly on which homes happened to close. The percent of original list received is the better measure, and it was 95.9% and 99.8% in those two months.
Will new construction add homes to choose from this winter? At Kelmscott Park, the City reported that all 12 single-family homes were sold, as were all 12 units in the second condominium building, as of April 30, 2026.
How long does a Lake Forest home take to sell? Detached homes averaged 31 days in September 2026, 56 days in January 2026 and 58 days over the 12 months through September 2026.
If you are deciding whether to shop Lake Forest this winter or wait until spring, The GGL Group would be glad to talk it through with you. We can sort the homes on your list by when they were first listed and look at this winter's contract pace together. Schedule a call when you are ready to start.